Mr. M used to make guns with foil at lunch time in the cafeteria, to the great consternation of school officials. In fact, I was told to stop sending anything in foil in his lunch.Schools don't like guns. I get that. I don't like them either. There's one kind of gun, though, that doesn't bother me: the kind little boys make with their hands.
But one dour public school in Michigan sees no distinction.
This past Wednesday, six-year old Mason Jammer was suspended from his kindergarten class at Jefferson Elementary School for pretending his hand was a gun and "aiming" it at another student.Whether he accompanied this terroristic threat with "pow pow pow!" remains unclear. The story is still breaking. You can see a video clip about it here.
This school probably banned "The Dangerous Book for Boys" from its library, too.
Sure, times have changed. I realize that. But come on. This is a bit much.Others look at the issue differently, of course. Indeed, some mothers are downright panicked over their sons' "violent tendencies." Here's an imploring entreaty posted by a mother on Berkley's "Parent Network" site:
I was wondering if people could offer some experience with boys and guns. I have 3 year old twin boys and everything is a gun. I mean the forks, the napkins, the blocks, etc. What is it from? What should I do? They watch some KQED and a few movies and videos. I thought I was choosing pretty non-violent stuff. I don't watch adult TV around them. We have tried talking to them about it. They don't have playdates with other kids. They get some at pre-school. But I want to raise non-violent boys. Any thoughts...thanks. (mother of future NRA member)
Still verklempt? Ivillage to the rescue:Provide kids with alternatives to gun play that help them feel powerful. Four- and five-year-olds love to be competent. Providing them with real work experiences such as carpentry, cooking, gardening can channel some of the energy being directed into gun play in a new, more creative direction.Carpentry, cooking and gardening? People. People!
Boys love guns, whether real or imagined. And their imaginations enable them to turn virtually anything into a weapon. It's innate.
Here's a clever snippet from a father's perspective, published in the Wall Street Journal:Not only do I believe that trying to take the wildness out of boys is a doomed social experiment, but I'm certain that genetic scientists will eventually discover that males carry the Cowboy Gene. That's my name for whatever is responsible for all the wrestling in my house, and the dunking during bath time, and my 5-year-old's insistence on wearing his silver six-shooters to Wal-Mart in order to protect our grocery cart. I only pray that when the Cowboy Gene is discovered, some well-meaning utopian doesn't try to transform it into a Tea Party Gene.There are plenty of things for us to worry about. We've got some pretty big fish to fry. And little boys playing with make-believe guns is not one of them.



11 comments:
I don't know if you've seen Bowling for Columbine, but I show clips of it in the anger management class I teach to teenagers.
There was a huge surge of fearmongering and zero tolerance policies after Columbine, and they show several news stories where a kindergartener was suspended after playing cops and robbers at recess, or another kid turned his chicken strip into a gun at lunch.
Sadly, not a new phenomenon, but a ridiculous one.
When I was a young mom, I was convinced by all the feminist literature that I should raise gender-neutral children. I gave it a shot--no guns, no trucks, no nothing masculine.
So imagine my surprise when my two year old, who had never SEEN a gun, picked up a stick in the backyard and made shooting noises.
My in-laws have never let me live that down.
Regardless, the point remains--boys will be boys, and any attempt to "legislate" a change in elementary psychology won't get you very far. I wonder if the ACLU is taking this case?
you have to be kidding me? I'm a Democrat, sure and I hate guns but what the fuck? That women is going to have to save her money for that poor kid's therapy b/c with a mother like that he is going to need it.
Tell ya what: I ain't a psychologist. I'm certainly not what I call a "libtard". Nor am I an NRA member, though I have been known to play one online.
As a boy, I played with the plastic guns and toy soldiers. I idolized John Wayne movies. I watched Combat and 12 O'Clock High. I read of the Revolutionary War, War of 1812, the Texas Revolution, the Mexican War, Civil War, plains Indian Wars, Spanish American War, WW I, WW II, Korea, Vietnam, Panama, Grenada, Gulf Wars I&II...
I watched the Three Stooges, Bugs Bunny, and all the slapstick and animated violence associated therein.
And in my 53 years, I've never shot anyone. Even those deserving it.
Now, I can imagine that some of these nannyists can't figure that one out, after what I've been exposed to.
Perhaps it's because I was educated in the "right vs wrong", "good vs evil" era, and not the social engineering, feminize boys era.
Just maybe.
I'm divided on this one... We don't allow toy guns in the house, yet if my boy wants to play make believe guns, he is allowed to... Although, I have to say, it gives me the creeps.
Oh Come on! What's next? Mean faces? The fish eye? How stupid. I guess Michigan's problems run deeper than unemployment.
I like that quote about the cowboy gene.
My boys have played with everything and love watching war movies with Hubs.
Oh and just yesterday I got a lesson on how much damage lightsabers can inflict. One strike and body parts can be severed as viewed by Anakin Skywalker in Episode 3.
More on our parenting--the boys already know that on most everything they do that's a bad choice--we will know about it.
Yeesh, suspended? In kindergarten? Even if you accept the fact that school should be a gunplay-free zone, aren't there about a million steps you could take before suspension? Such as looking at the kid and saying "Uh uh. No guns."
Maybe they should give him a whippin' with an imaginary switch, that worked for my meemaw (only she used a real one).
One of my pediatricians developmental tests for 4 year olds was to put items (like a grape, rock, stick and graham cracker) and see if they chose to use any items as a weapon.
It was considered Normal and a development milestone.
Lady Fi, you know I love you . . . but on this one it's not even a close call for me. Gun (or weapon) play is simply what little boys do. It's in their genes. I agree with Madame Mayor: it's a developmental milestone and certainly nothing to get creeped out about. Sounds to me like you've got a normal healthy son.
Some people just need to get a life! Violence is a part of the human condition; some people are going to die "before their time". Sorry about that. It hurts, I know, but you can't do anything about it so GET OVER IT!
Our entire society is filled with people looking to blame someone else for perfectly normal but unpleasant happenings. I have to carry insurance against someone falling on my property and being injured - even if the person is there with a gun planning on killing me. Bah humbug! There's a lot wrong in paradise.
Post a Comment